An Informed Public is the Best Civil Defense
With just several weeks to go before the most consequential U.S. election since the 1864 blowout between President Abraham Lincoln and New Jersey’s General George McClellan it’s not likely that the accelerating collapse of authenticated local news will surface in what’s left of the national campaign.
Like so many vital issues, this trend is playing out at the local level and requires a granular grasp of detail that just doesn’t make it on to the national radar particularly if it exposes the dark side of late-stage vulture capitalism that’s pumping hundreds of millions into the campaign.
It’s like the bone headed decision by the Biden White House last year declaring the COVID Public Health Emergency over and greenlighting the states to “unwind” Medicaid which led to well over 20 million Americans losing their healthcare. You wouldn’t have noticed the real-world impact of that unless you had to visit one of our nation’s crowded Emergency Rooms where the once insured now show up for basic healthcare.
All the news that really matters is usually very local like which way a forest fire is heading.
Authenticating news all comes down to the vital exercise of asking yourself how you know what you know. It’s a discipline every real journalist and news consumer needs to ask yet these days all too often the answer to that essential question is ‘I saw it on the internet’ or on social media on my cell phone.
No doubt behemoths like Meta, aka Facebook and X, aka Twitter, are thrilled that thanks to our reliance on our cellphones our situational awareness is bathed in streams of unauthenticated stories like Trump’s click bait whopper about Haitian immigrants eating the local pets of folks in Ohio. These days, the “news” you get on your phone is based on a compendium of analytics tracking both your past consumer choices and most intimate cyber explorations.
It’s all individuated—customized to your prejudices, previous bad choices, and past dining out experiences. While this current media market earns its architects billions it leaves us diminished with real civil defense implications like the bomb scares called into Ohio in the aftermath of the pet eating hoax.
Should we be surprised that in this degraded news environment we don’t have a national consensus on who won the 2020 election or on how best to confront a life-threatening disease like COVID?
Legacy news organizations still doing journalism, like the New York Times and the Wall Street Journal, have steep paywalls that offer levels of access to news for a price. If you want an ad free option it always cost you.
Free press? Not unless you own one.
For a generation we have had a conglomerate like Gannett buy up locally owned newspapers that were published and produced by people with an authentic connection to their community. In short order, Gannett sells off the physical location of the newspaper, radically cuts the reporting staff, and replaces locally sourced journalism with aggregated content from nowhere in particular.
Similarly, in the broadcast world we’ve seen giant conglomerates buy up locally owned outlets and replicate Gannett’s strategy. Don’t be surprised if you miss a brewing tornado because your favorite radio station is giving you the weather from the other side of the country.
Content on Fox and MSNBC generally re-enforces the worldview of the consumers tuning in. Of course, in the de-regulated world of cable the news and public affairs function once carried by FCC regulated broadcasters has morphed into partisan cheerleading.
In just the last few weeks we’ve seen the dismantling of WCBS News radio, one of only two all-news outlets left in our region and major staff cuts at WNYC which is branded as both New York Public Radio and New Jersey Public Radio.
Back in 1997, then Mayor Rudy Giuliani decided to sell off WNYC, the storied municipally owned radio station, to a non-profit that would go on to pay its CEO in excess of one million dollars a year and permit her to sit on the board of directors of the Tribune Media Company.
Of course, WNYC’s New Jersey Public Radio off-shoot was created after former Gov. Chris Christie dismantled our state’s public TV and radio the New Jersey Network. That move split New Jersey’s public radio constellation that took years to assemble up between the New York City centric WNYC and the Philadelphia centric WHYY.
WNYC got WNJT-88.1 FM Trenton, WNJP 88.5 FM Sussex, WNJY 89.3 FM Netcong and WNJO- 90.3 FM Toms River/Seaside Park.
WHYY acquired WNJZ 90.3 FM Cape May Court House, WNJM 89.9 FM Manahawkin, WNJN 89.7 FM Atlantic City, WNJB 89.3 FM Bridgeton and WNJS 88.1 FM Berlin.
The venerable NJN-TV, which provided live gavel to gavel coverage of the 2001 bombshell New Jersey State Senate Judiciary Committee hearings into the New Jersey State Police use of racial profiling, was sold off to WNET, PBS in our region.
Back in April, WNET CEO Neal Shapiro announced cuts to NJ Spotlight News. In November, WNET whacked MetroFocus, its essential daily local news program. Of course, Shapiro gets $854,024 in annual compensation according to ProPublica, the non-profit investigative reporting website.
See a pattern?
All too often a non-profit claiming to act in the public interest on public affairs swallows up what was a public asset, carries it for a while only to shrink it while paying its executives Wall Street like salaries.
How many local reporters can you get for a million dollars?
Legacy media like the NYT and Wall Street Journal, along with the Leftist-controlled propaganda TV media, CBS, NBC, ABC, PBS, CNN, MSNBC have gone down the black hole of corporate controlled Leftist Media and most Americans have seen through it and have stopped reading or believing it.
Mainstream Legacy Media is a failed institution that will soon enough fall by the wayside. People no longer get or want their news from these Deep State constructs. People see through the propaganda of these media outlets as being nothing more than an arm of the Left-wing Deep State. Americans are fed up with Legacy Media and it shows in the polls that Legacy Media is at a nadir when it ranks at or below the level of politicians.
Legacy Media is dead or dying and will be a thing of the past. Local news is nothing more than a police blotter, weather and sports, and Left-wing slanted political short stories. It has nothing to offer the public anymore. That’s why Americans have resorted to finding real news on the internet, and elsewhere.
Yes, Bob, you are absolutely right and this is a very important analysis. In my lane, I’ve witnessed the virtual evaporation of the Trenton State House press corps and the subject matter environmental reporters at all the regional and local papers and news outlets. So it’s not just fine grain local that’s gone. And even NJ Spotlight, which started out with a public policy/public interest oriented mission, has gone steeply downhill. Tom Johnson retired and I did’t even see a goodbye.
Mr. Jefferson (I’ve read Jefferson, and you are no Jefferson): You are almost a parody of exactly the problems that Bob wrote about as deeply problematic.
Do you eat dead cats too? Or your neighbor’s dogs? Just askin’.
Bob Wolfe: You’re a funny guy!!!! I’m wondering if you’re projecting your own dietary needs. I believe that you’re a “roadkill” guy. Keep on trolling.
There are few shining lights left, such as Pacifica (here in metropolitan New York, that is WBAI, 99.5 FM, struggling mightily). I’ve been glad to see some good reporting still at The Record, but not nearly as much as previously, especially after Gannett itself got bought up.
This should be obligatory reading for every local news consumer in America. You’ve covered the essence of what local reporting is and how corporate takeovers have taken this away from communities – leaving a big hole in its wake.