CAN NJ TRANSIT BE SAVED? CORBETT AT THE ONE YEAR MARK
Listen to audio version of this article
Feb. 14 will mark the one year anniversary of New Jersey Transit’s Executive Director Kevin S. Corbett, who was picked by Gov. Phil Murphy to turn around the beleaguered agency.
On paper, Corbett, a top executive with AECOM, an international infrastructure company, had a solid track record for handling complex projects with many moving parts. Over the arc of his public service career he played key roles in the redevelopment of Times Square and the post 9/11 revitalization of economic activity in Lower Manhattan.
As challenging as those past assignments were, turning around the nation’s third largest transit system has proved quite a challenge because the agency comes with so much baggage. During the eight years of Governor Chris Christie tenure the state’s transit system was used as a prop by the Governor, much like the GWB was used, to send a political message that had nothing to do with transportation. And to add insult to his injury, I never actually saw the Governor ride New Jersey Transit.
So, how is Mr. Corbett doing?
As a New Jersey commuter for forty years and a former employee of New Jersey Transit’s precursor, the Erie Lackawanna, I feel I can offer an informed opinion. That assessment is not just based on my decades tenure as a long suffering customer on the Morris & Essex line, but on the fact that Corbett actually rides the train everyday from Morristown. So, I have been able to see him in action as a fully engaged chief executive.
I was listening while he was engaged in a coaching conversation with a train conductor after the conductor was speaking negatively about train engineers who called out sick. What struck me was Corbett’s balanced tone. It was corrective, but respectful in a way that did not diminish the employee he was speaking with.
At 63, I know what moral leadership looks and sounds like and that was as close an approximation as New Jersey Transit has seen for awhile. Sadly, over the years its upper management has been a place to park partisan political operatives.
As NorthJersey.com reported last year, nine of Christie’s operatives planted in New Jersey Transit enjoyed six-figure salaries that included an instance of a $70,000 spike in salary even “as it hemorrhaged staff needed to operate safely and reliably.”
Of course, this Machiavellian stacking of a vital transportation agency with political hacks was exactly what the former Governor did with the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey.
Christie’s call to cancel the building of the ARC Tunnel under the Hudson River let the GOP presidential primary electorate know he was a fiscal conservative. But in reality, it squandered hundreds of millions of dollars in engineering and land acquisition for a project that was well underway when Christie applied the brakes.
For years, commuters have complained about the deterioration in service that came even as the fares continued to go up. That sub-par performance was aggravated by NJ Transit’s self-inflicted wound in 2013 that came when managers failed to properly prepare for Sandy, leaving the agency’s fleet of locomotives and passenger coaches vulnerable to that storm surge it produced. $120 million in damage was done.
Meanwhile, across the river, the MTA, faced with the same unprecedented severe weather, avoided a similar calamity thanks to climate change vulnerability studies it had previously developed with Columbia University’s Lamont Doherty Observatory.
And the legacy of Christie’s reign of misrule lingers to this day.
Back in December, Bloomberg News reported that nearly “a third of New Jersey Transit’s rush-hour trains to and from Manhattan arrived late in November” and that “overall timeliness for the trouble-plagued agency plunged to 82 percent, the lowest for a November since at least 2003 and down from 92 percent a year earlier.”
But with that pain has come some considerable gain in the form of the near completion of the system wide installation of positive train control (PTC), an advanced automatic collision avoidance system that can stop a train before accidents occur.
Back in September of 2016 the lack of that system was a contributing factor in the train crash that killed one person, injured over a hundred others and caused $6 million in damage to the Hoboken Terminal. The National Transportation Safety Board also concluded that the primary cause of the fatal crash was a fatigued NJ Transit engineer, suffering from undiagnosed sleep apnea, who lost consciousness as he approached the Hoboken terminal.
Before Corbett took over NJ Transit, the PTC was running way behind schedule and the price tag, at $320 million, had more than doubled in price, When Governor Murphy took office in 2017 most of the installation was still incomplete.
“We’ve had to complete four years’ worth of work in less than one year and we are not finished,” Corbett told the NJ Transit Board, Bloomberg News reporter. “We’ll have to complete another four years’ worth of work over the next two years to have PTC fully operational by the federal mandated deadline of Dec. 31. 2020.”
The kind of cronyism that took hold at NJ Transit under Christie is corrosive. When politics eclipses performance, it undermines how all the ‘un-connected’ employees feel about their job. Rather than it being about what you know, it becomes all about who you know.
By contrast, Corbett’s actual daily engagement with the workforce has already resulted in a morale boost. When polled, the NJ Transit employees I have encountered, who were not cleared to speak with the press, had words of praise for Mr. Corbett’s hands on style of leadership.
“Of course it makes a difference for us that he rides the train everyday,” said one NJ Transit veteran. “That’s where you lead, from the front.”
Next time you see Mr. Corbett, ask him to just come out and announce that New Jersey Transit has no intention of resuming Princeton Junction-Princeton Dinky shuttle train service. Last October they “suspended” the Dinky in favor of bus service, which takes longer and is subject to weather delays. During the snowstorm of November 15, the bus covering for the “suspended” Dinky made me two hours late arriving to Princeton Junction from Princeton. Had the Dinky been running, the trip would have taken five minutes.
N.J. Transit used the positive train control project and so-called shortage of engineers as reasons to stop Dinky service. Four months since all this started, I am waiting for a journalist to 1) point out that P.T.C. does not affect the Dinky line, which runs slowly with no turns, and 2) ask how the railroad suddenly had too few engineers despite running many fewer trains during this P.T.C. endeavor.
It has to be that New Jersey Transit wants to stop the Dinky, permanently. When “suspending” the Dinky last fall N.J. Transit said service would resume in January 2019. Then in January they went back on their word, saying the Dinky won’t be back until “the second quarter of 2019,” which could be as late as June 30.
The Dinky won’t be back as late as June 30, as it won’t be back at all. As if the two nonexistent reasons to suspend Dinky service in the first place were not loud enough hints, one should note the head counts N.J. Transit personnel take when you ride the bus running in place of the Dinky. New Jersey Transit is working on getting so many Dinky riders fed up that they drive between Princeton Junction and Princeton or use a car service. I see fewer familiar faces on these bus rides than I did on the Dinky. This will keep up until N.J. Transit can claim, “So few people now travel between Princeton and Princeton Junction that New Jersey Transit cannot justify resuming Dinky train service. Bus transportation will be permanent.”
Even worse, once they make Princeton Junction-Princeton bus transportation permanent New Jersey Transit will include other stops on that trip. It won’t be a direct station-to-station route, which takes ten to fifteen minutes. The Dinky took five minutes; when the bus becomes permanent, people should brace themselves for a journey of twenty-five to thirty minutes.
So, please tell Kevin Corbett to tell the truth. He should get it over with, and be sure to send flowers.
One last thing: A previous N.J. Transit executive director took the train every day. His name was James Weinstein and his boss was Chris Christie.