Mukherji, other Lawmakers, Grapple with the End of an Era
Raj Mukherji, a state senator from Hudson County, made an overall point.
“It’s just sad that we have to do this.”
This was officially about legal ads, but Mukherji’s lament was that his local newspaper, the Jersey Journal, will close early next year.
Newspapers have published legal ads – official government notices – for decades. They include budgets, ordinances, meeting notices and more. Cost is determined by the size of the ad and the newspaper’s circulation.
Plummeting print newspaper circulation has prompted talk of allowing these notices to be placed on government websites, which would save towns and school districts money.
The issue became more pressing about two months ago when the Star Ledger announced it would cease printing a newspaper as of next February. Two other papers – the Times of Trenton and the South Jersey Times – will follow suit.
So, how can legal ads be published in a printed newspaper if one does not exist?
The Warren County Commissioners made the issue even more pressing by filing suit against the Ledger and the Morristown Daily Record, seeking permission to put legal ads online. A hearing on the suit is set for Jan. 6 in Somerset County.
In the meantime, the Senate Judiciary Committee on Monday backed a very interim solution.
Beginning Jan. 1 and running through March 1, legal ads could be placed on a newspaper’s website. This would allow ads to be “published” in papers that will no longer have a print edition.
However, the cost will be the same as placing them in a newspaper.
That makes this proposal merely a stopgap. It gives towns and school boards, which hold reorganization meetings in early January, an outlet for legal notices. But it does not save them money.
So, a permanent solution will be needed after March. That likely will allow legal ads to be placed on a municipal or school district website.
This may solve the legal notice problem, but let’s go back to Mukherji’s point.
Hudson County, which has about 700,000 people and an unlimited amount of – shall we say – interesting politics, will soon have no daily newspaper. The Hudson Dispatch, which was based in Union City, closed decades ago,
This cannot be good for democracy. If you wish to blame anyone, blame corporate ownership of newspapers, whose concern is simple – squeeze as much profit as possible out of a publication by cutting and cutting and cutting. Local news is not a priority.
Politicians like to criticize the press. And let’s not forget that the Legislature and governor a few months ago gutted the state’s Open Public Records Act.
Still, one supposes there is an acknowledgment in Trenton that newspapers are important. After all, politicians certainly read them.
Now, some local papers are disappearing or ending print editions, which makes them less visible.
Mukherji was thinking about Hudson County, but his comment about a post-newspaper world was not limited to geography. He said at the close of Monday’s committee hearing:
“It speaks to an uncertain future.”
Mr. Snowflack,
Thank you very much for writing this article and drawing much-needed attention to this very important issue. Senator Mukherji is to be commended for raising this issue. I sincerely hope all his other colleagues that represent Hudson County on the state, county, and municipal levels join him to arrive at the best possible solution moving forward, to not only address the importance of the regular publication of current municipal and county legal notices in easily accessible media, but to find suitable replacements to fill the huge void in local and county news that will exist after February, when the last county-wide newspaper, the Jersey Journal, which has covered the news faithfully here since 1867 folds. As an author, my second book, the History of West New York, New Jersey could not have been written without my access to various Jersey Journal news clippings on hand at the Museum of the West New York Public Library, as well as the extensive online Jersey Journal database available at Jersey City Public Library online resources, via Newsbank, Inc. Our generation and future generations will not have access to newsworthy information concerning what happens in Hudson County after February, 2025 on a similar scale to what we have enjoyed from the Jersey Journal since 1867. ( or from the Hudson Reporter, which also folded not too long ago.) Of course, county-wide online news providers like John Heinis’ Hudson County View, or it’s rival, Hudson TV will continue to serve us well, but that is very clearly not enough. The Record, formerly known as The Bergen Record, is delivered daily to the West New York Library. Perhaps enough Hudson County leaders on the local, county and state level can work in concert to influence the publishers of The Record to expand their coverage area to include Hudson County, of which it’s lands east of the Hackensack River, of course, is the oldest part of the original Bergen County. In addition, the Observer, in existence since the 1880’s , a weekly newspaper that serves Kearny, Harrison and East Newark in both a print, as well as online edition, could be enlisted to expand its coverage into the rest of Hudson County. Let us do what we can to insure that our local and county news will surely continue to be reported daily and weekly in hard copy as well as online fashion, so that a faithful testament of thriving local communities is told and recorded for current and future generations.
Patrick Cullen, M.A.
Museum of the
West New York Public Library
425 60th Street
West New York, NJ 07093
201-295-5135 x7308